alicornucopia: (Default)
[personal profile] alicornucopia posting in [community profile] belltower
So we've started answering comments in "How To Read Effulgence" in character, and that's not really the ideal platform for those conversations. This is! You may address characters here and we may opt to answer in character. You will get a kind of loosely "backstage" out-of-continuity version of the character (in continuity proper, you cannot talk to them, since you aren't there) and if you want them at a specific (past relative to where we're writing) point in time, feel free to specify (e.g. "Addy in 1932", "Shell in her box", "the Joker while committed", "Minus right after he woke up from turning", "the alethiometer on the subject of 1207").

Any glowfic author may use this thread to receive questions.

You may also be interested in Make My Characters Talk To Each Other.

Re: Some random questions

Date: 2015-11-26 08:37 am (UTC)
From: [personal profile] daniel_h
Having thought about it some more since my last reply, I have a minor comment about this and two further questions.

First, the comment. Most of the metaphor was quite useful, but there is one thing that has been bugging me. I would be so bad at minting if coins were made out of boredom. As soon as I made a coin I would stop being bored because I had magic. This would eventually wear off, but it couldn't do it quickly because that would require me to get used to having coins, which I couldn't do while generating them so slowly.

Now, for the first question. Suppose that, before becoming a mint yourself, you heard that Lazarus had made a bunch of unusuals and uniques. I imagine that when he came by to unshren you and Finnah, you would have asked about that; you've said several times that you wanted more form choices. From my understanding of the magic involved, it would be impossible to have an unusual or unique shren; given the choice between "unique dragon" and "shren", which would you have chosen? I suppose Lazarus could also have offered you a shapeshifting power unrelated to your species, but for all I know such a power would have weird interactions with your existing forms. You could probably have designed a suitable power yourself eventually, but at this point you didn't know you'd become a mint and Lazarus was busy curing all the other shrens.

Finally, Lazarus did not give any of the baby shrens a choice about whether to become dragons or not, and given the circumstances this was probably the right choice (even if you would trust 20-year-old dragonishes with such a big question, speed was probably more important in this case). Suppose that for some reason you were given the choice of turning into a dragon or not when you were partly through a 20-year course of esu. Would your answer have been different in that case?

Re: Some random questions

Date: 2015-11-26 02:27 pm (UTC)
thisvorlunatic: (⑪ theoretical)
From: [personal profile] thisvorlunatic
Re: the comment, yeah, I anticipated something like that, which is why I added "or some other trivially inconvenient state of mind".

Interestingly enough, I'd have to double-check with Lazarus but from my current understanding of the theory involved it is possible to have a unique shren, the same way you get a shren parunia.

Given I'd be, one, a baby, and two, partly through a 20-year course of esu... I'd say it depends. If it was after I invented the word e'sisaak but before things got really bad, I bet I'd be stubborn. If it was while things were in the middle of getting really bad, it would depend what mood they caught me in. If it was after things had definitely gotten really bad, I'd probably stick it out just because I was constantly living in the victory-at-any-cost state of mind at that point.

But if I did decide to give up shrenhood as a baby, it would probably take me only a few more decades to figure out that I regretted it. Whether or not I'd regret it enough to change back... I really couldn't say.

Profile

belltower: (Default)
The Belltower

October 2013

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
1314151617 1819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 26th, 2025 02:40 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios